A smash classic. If you are on the LIE you better stop here and grab a classic slice and a brothers special. Yum This is the old school New York City pizza joint. Super friendly staff. Was really awesome to sit at the counter and talk about pizza history. Ordered a brother’s special pie. While I was sitting I did order a classic slice. The sauce was so delicious. The cheese was the perfect amount. The fold man o man. You have to fold this one. I took a photo of the Brothers special before it went into the oven. Wow I sat at the bar and just took in the heavenly aroma. Brother’s special pie comes with sausage, red peppers, mushrooms, pepperoni, onions, and meatball. All in all this is the place you want to get a slice at. The pictures don’t do justice to the FLAVOR. classic decor and good hospitable New York workers.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$20–30

Had previous eaten 2x at this local pizza place. I heard about it from a neighbor but since its not near the house, i never go there. The last 2 times we had just plain pizza by the slice, this time we ordered a large pie with mushroom and sausage. The sausage is sliced into small rounds and it slicex very thin, the mushrooms were in every crevice of the pie so the pie was loaded with the 2 toppings. I called ahead of time and within 20 minutes i drove to pick it up. We are excited that we found a new Pizza place since Gino and Villa rustica are 5 mins away from my house but their pizza quality had gone down. Thankfully, we have a new pizza spot and we cannot wait to try the rest of the menu. I love the pizza because they manage to make the dough thin, the sauce has a nice ting and it ia very flavorful. Just perfect pizza every time. Seems to be a husband and wife team that run the place.

I know I'm going to take grief for this one but I didn't find this place to appealing . I liked that the place appeared like it hasn't been remodeled in since the 80s . It had an old school vintage appearance . So i checked online and found out that this place is the number one rated slice in NYC. Being a big pizza lover that title comes with a lot of respect and pressure to keep it up . I ordered a plain cheese slice and it wasn't anything crazy . The sauce and the cheese are what makes a pizza and quite frankly both were just as about average as I've ever had . I wouldn't come back after the heart break. The worse part about this experience was that I asked for a take home slice and the guy serving me was being so lazy that he asked if I wanted it heated because it made no sense for him to heat it . Unbelievable !!!

Quintessential New York pizzaria full of friendly banter and pride in their craft. I heard a customer come in and ask if Brothers had the best pizza in the neighborhood. The reply, "I don't know about the rest of the neighborhood but we're the best on this block". (Just imagine that with a fast spoken heavy NY accent). My wife had a delicious salad and we split the "Brothers Special" pie which is loaded with everything except anchovies and pineapple. (Meatball, mushrooms, sausage, roasted red pepper, onion, pepperoni and minced garlic in oil.) Each slice was thin crust with light sauce and large in flavor. Don't miss this if you're in the area! Thanks Brothers from your Houston friends!

My favorite local pizzeria. If you grew up in Queens then this place will definitely give you nostalgia with the decor and counter seating. The inside will seldomly get a little crowded with students or a kids baseball team but the service is still quick and I’ve never had trouble finding a seat. The food is amazing. Pizza, chicken parm, or the sausage/peppers are my usual orders. Been going here almost 15 years
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Veal Parmigiana, Cheese Pizza Slice, Large Plain Pizza, Cheese Pizza Pie

I ordered a large cheese half mushroom pie last night from Brothers Pizza. I like my pizza crust on the lighter side & this pie was over baked for me. I called Brothers, they were so nice, listened to my concern and delivered a fresh pie within 20 minutes, that was PERFECT! (same delivery person, sweet, kind, apologetic) 5 minutes after the pie was delivered, Brothers called to follow up. The pizza was great, the customer service outstanding! Thank you Brothers Pizza for providing quality service, your customers appreciate it!
Service
Delivery
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10

This is probably the BEST PIZZA in NY. Everyone in NY says they have a GREAT pizza place, but most don't know about how good NYC Pizza used to be like 30 years ago. This place has REAL NYC PIZZA. THE way NYC Pizza always was 30+ years ago. Nowadays most Pizza places are just horrible, i don't understand why. This place is just AWESOME. They also make their calzones FRESH. Unlike most Pizza places that have them sitting around for weeks until someone orders one, and they reheat it and serve.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Let me first say thank you brothers for delivering out of the normal range of delivery. The pizza was exactly how I asked it to be made and really was one of the best pizzas i’ve had in a long time. I asked for extra sauce light cheese and a little well done. Wow I already ate the entire pie and I just got it 15 min ago. I’ve been going to brothers for A good 15 years or more. They are the best and only great pizza left in Flushing / Fresh Meadows area. Thanks again for the great food and Happy Mother’s Day weekend to my Brothers !

Ordered through Uber Eats. Pizza arrived with no seal on the box and the box half way open. Can’t blame the delivery person because the pizza was too large for the box. To make matters worse the pizza was undercooked and soggy. Even the sausage and meatballs were undercooked. We had to place the entire pizza in the oven at 400 degrees for 1/2 hour—that’s how undercooked the pizza was. In the past year this is the first food delivery we’ve received that wasn’t sealed. First and last time ordering from this place.

Fantastic food. Wonderful owner and attentive staff. Delicious. We ordered home made minestrone, antipasta salad, chicken parm, ziti, spaghetti, Italian sausage and peppers. Would come again a million times if we could.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free street parking
Parking
Plenty of parking all around the location

This is about the cheese pizza pie with vegetables: it seems like they carelessly pile up a lot of uncooked and old raw onions, excessive and raw garlic, canned mushrooms and old broccoli on top a regular pizza The result: a completely unpleasant, gross looking pizza with a horrible taste and after taste that lasts for hours. Take a look at the completely white raw onion, the spoonfuls of raw garlic in just a section of one of the slices, and the unmistakable look of canned mushrooms.

Old school classic pizza spot. first time visiting and won't be my last. I got the pepperoni pie. Love the thin crust. I read some complaints about it, so i was concerned. It's tasty and perfect. Fold it like a NYer! You'll be fine. Sauce was tasty. Everyone was nice and friendly, even though i messed up their napkin holder (oops) thanks for the laugh. Great way to end my work day.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Arguably the best pizza in Queens. Definitely the best chicken rolls in Queens. Every roll is fresh made to order so it takes some time but its worth it. If you like old school they give off that old school mom and pop vibe which jives well with me given many of the pizza spots in Queens have a factory assembly line you're in and out feel. Definitely recommend it to anyone that is into trying all of the cities famous pizzerias.

Decent pizza, not great. Especially on their Monday $9.99 pies, they're extremely stingy on the cheese. Like less than frozen Totinos. Parking is horrible. I'll sometimes have to go around the block 6 or 7 times before I get pissed and park in the lot down the street. Sometimes I wonder why I even keep going here. Its because then I don't have to decide what to eat on Mondays, and deciding is the worst part of dinner.

Really good! Sauce was delicious and the crust was thin but had substance. And being able to see them making everything was super cool. Overall, it seems like a nice neighborhood place and you can tell that they have a connection to their community because they were carrying on a conversation with a couple people at the bar and they were very friendly towards us, obvious tourists. We definitely will be coming back.

Awesome neighborhood pizzeria, while I wouldn't call it the best slice in New York the quality and taste is up there. If you happen to be around the Fresh Meadows area be sure to stop by for a slice. This pizzeria can get busy around the afternoons on weekdays as they run specials for students from nearby high schools. Owner and staff are always friendly and helpful. Glad to give them my business anytime.

Been ordering pizza from this pizzeria for the last 18 months. While i live on the neighborhood for 12 years, i found out about their delicious pizza because of a friend. I can only tell you their pizza is cheesee, great sauce and they have a monday night special for $9.99 for a plain pie. They are generous with the toppings. We usually get mushroom and sausage and its an excellent combo.

Great pizza, great service, love this place....... I go as often as I can..... great prices as well! I don't live in the area, but anytime I pass by Brothers on the L.I.E. I have to stop for a slice or more......
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Cheese Pizza Slice

There's a reason this place continues to hang around since forever. Best pizza in the neighborhood by far. One of the best in the city. If you go in here for a slice, you will not be disappointed. Guaranteed.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 3
Recommended dishes
Cheese Pizza Slice

Great pizzas and heroes prepared as you wish, staff friendly and happy to have this welcoming living room for everyone wanting delicious food in a clean cozy Italian restaurant.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pepperoni Slice, Cheese Pizza Slice, Garlic

Lived in bayside for 2 years and I just found real Pizza. Thin crust is perfect. I even got a chicken roll and Italian ice to go. Will be back
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Cheese Pizza Slice
Recommendation for vegetarians
Highly recommend

Good pizza but when I arrived and asked if it was cash only and the dude explicitly said I can use card if we spend $10 or more. We spend $18 and try to pay and he says sorry, no cards. House rules. That wouldn't have been a huge deal since there was an ATM down the street but we ordered a lot more than we wanted so we could use the card and avoid an ATM fee.

Classic solid pizza joint near the Hampton Jitney stop in Queens. I asked for a grandma slice and they made it homemade just one slice instead of making me a whole pie really good pasta with broccoli and garlic and olive oil solid pizzas and great Italian ices. Definitely a must if you need real NY pizza.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Brother's Pizza is a classic pizza staple location in Fresh Meadows. Everything from the atmosphere to service is up to standard. Come here if you want to get a quick lunch of pizza.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 4
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Cheese Pizza Slice

There is no better pizzeria period! No clue why Dave P from bar stool hasn't stop by yet... But for me , pizza coming out of the oven is a 9.2.. A must for any pizza lover..
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Cheese Pizza Slice

Delicious sauce and chees on top of the pizza, lovely buffalo chicken wings and very fresh vegetables on antipasto salad!!!! They delivered our food super fast! Thanks a lot
Service
Delivery
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes
Cheese Pizza Slice, Salad

This has your standard New York slice pretty good slice could use a little more sauce and a little more crisp however the crust had good crisp which was good. The Sicilian slice was a little too thick for my liking amount of cheese was perfect just needed more sauce as well will try the grandma slice next time but overall good spot

Best Pizza in Town period!!! Don’t waste your time going anywhere else. When you go there ask for Lupe Or Dennis the owner them Mario sent you. 5 stars across the Board. Best Pizza !!!
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10
Kid-friendliness
They treat your kids as if they were their own.

I ordered from here for the first time. Delivery was quick. I ordered the spaghetti and red clam sauce. I asked for extra sauce and actually got it inside. Most places I order from are stingy with the sauce. Looking forward to ordering from there again.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20

Layout/atmosphere *Counter area with stools; tables in the back; three TVs; enclosed outdoor dining structure in street Service *Friendly Food/drink *Regular slice - good *Square slice - Good; very cheesy [Standard pizza toppings/slice selection]
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10

The best pizza and chicken roll we ever had! Would give more than 5 stars if could. Never go anywhere else.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Cheese Pizza Slice, Chicken Roll

Great food. Had the lemon Italian ice, pizza and beef patty. Superceded my expectations. Would definitely return if in NYC!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Cheese Pizza Pie

Shared a pizza with my brother, ate outside in the little structure they built in the street out front. The pizza was delicious! We had half sausage and red bell peppers, half plain cheese. Doesn't get much better. The guys behind the counter were friendly and personable. A legit 5-star pizzeria!

Decent pizza. Could've been a fluke, but my pie's crust was soggy and thin. Definitely too much tomato sauce. Speaking of which, the tomato sauce was just ok—not sweet or salty enough for my taste. I'm being picky, I know, but I know what I like. I'd eat here again, just not a first choice.

This place was a really surprisingly good pizza spot. It doesn't look like much from the outside, and is in a very random location, but the pizza was killer. They only do round and Sicilian - no toppings, but they do it fantastically. So far my favorite pizza place in Queens.

Cash only. Simple & classic pizza recipe that the two brothers started when they first opened. Thin crust that's crunchy and pizza that's juicy with flavor. Fun fact: The pizza is bigger then the box it comes in! Definitely worth every penny. $14 for a plain and $2 toppings.

Brothers Pizza, is absolutely an old school pizza spot with the best pizza. If you want to cinch that craving, this is where to get your pizza. The pizza is crispy on the bottom, and perfectly cheesy on top, I can have slice after slice and still want more.

This review is just for the garlic knots and the regular slices. I am giving it a solid four out of five stars. The garlic knots however are probably best I ever tasted. They were firm and moist and Not dried out. so definitely 4.5 stars on these here knots

Been goin here for over 25yrs!! Best Pizza in Queens! Try the Beef patty with pepperoni and cheese…it’s delicious!!! The staff is incredibly helpful and courteous. Pizza is always fresh and tasty! Recommend this spot to anybody looking for a tasteful pizza

This place, yammy...best pizza in Queens for sure, no doubt about it! One of the best pizzas I ever had, honestly! Also ... Alec Baldwin is a visitor in here , he loves it too! Out of all pizza places, pick this one, I guarantee the best pizza and more ..

Pizza so thin I could see through it. They must have won Guiness world record with it. Even the Domino's Thin Crust is 12 layers thicker than this. If you want real NYC pizza this place ain't it. Highly do not recommend I dunno why it has 4.6 stars.

Small slice for $3.25. A little heavy on the oregano, but has a flavorful sauce. Thin, crispy , chewy crust with good flavor. Skimps overall on cheese, and, it's somewhat undercooked.. Too much crust left uncovered. I'll give it an 85 rating.

Walked passed and discovered this very affordable pizza joint in Fresh Meadows, Queens. You can get a pizza with a topping for under twenty before tax. Tried takeout for the first time and it was very good! Good stringy cheese, very thin

Unforgettable pizza, good bang for your buck. This is my go to pizza spot. They also serve a personal favorite of mine, baked clams. They were just delicious beyond description. Keep it up! The workers and owner are extremely friendly.

Best pizza in Queens hands down and the staff is amazing and friendly. Mozzarella sticks and chicken parmesan are out of this world. Want a quick bite they are great to catch before a movie down the block. Great for date night too!!

Baked ziti was bland pasta with decent sauce. Pizza was good, maybe, but it tasted like there was soap. This might be because the guy making it didn't adequately rinse his hands of soap (I watched him wash his hands several times).

Oily reg. pizza.. Not as good as Napoli pizza on 69th Ave the Sicilian is better than the reg
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 3
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 3

What is there not to love about Brothers Pizza?! The food is absolutely delicious and the fellas who work there are always kind and courteous! The environment is always homey and welcoming! Highly recommend, friends!

Stand up owners. Pizza just as good. Don’t go anywhere else. Been living in fresh meadows for 2 years now. Could just use a hair more sauce. Crust is on point along with flavor and cheese. No other place comes close.

Ordered a pie and was told 25-30 min. Waited over an hour for it to finally come cold and burnt underneath. Counter worker was nasty over the phone also. I’m sticking to Divinos much better place and welcoming staff.

The staff is nice. I went in with a group of 6 (2 adults and 4 children) and decided to buy two cheese pies. The pizza is not too thick but yet has a really nice chrunch. Only 1 slice was left. I would visit again.

I am pleased with their pizza, and their soup is also good.the minestrone soup.the man that takes your order over the phone is also very friendly! They also deliver in a timely fashion,when they say they will. More

If you’re in queens and have a hunger for a good slice, then this is definitely the place you want to eat at. Fresh pizza, friendly staff, and there’s a decent amount of seating. Their grandma slices are amazing.

Very friendly pizzeria. Food is great. I got best Sicilian. I highly recommend.
Service
Delivery
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Not too bad. Guy who was working there was nice. Pizza was pretty good and garlic knots were good too. Parking isn't the greatest on this main road, its metered parking unless you park on the side streets.

Original! Friendly entertaining staff and a great tasting pizza in Queens. Sure, we will eat here again during our next visit here! Thank you for the great dinner. It was delicious and fun! Thank you.

Easily the best Sicilian-style pizza in Queens! Maybe even all of NYC.
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Sicilian Slice

If you are at a hotel across the freeway, this place is a must. $2.75 for regular slice of pizza and let me tell you, best darn pizza in the world. Get up off your butt and walk over there!

Quite possibly the best pizza I have ever had. So delicious with an amazing crunchy but light base. A definite must if you are in the neighbourhood! Staff were super friendly as well!

Always love this place! Super fresh, same taste all the time! Very affordable! Absolutely love their service! Was just in with my little guy and they made him feel super special!

Yummy pizza with the friendly staff and reasonable price. I went there during quarantine, they were very busy with takeouts and delivery. Still manage to gave me pizza on time.

One of the best NY slices I have had which was so surprising. Will definitely come back. The Mets decor was an added bonus
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Been eating here for the last 23 years. Best pizza ive ever had and its always consistent. Has never tasted any different all these years, and the garlic knots are delicious.

Went over to get some slices for dinner and both the NY and Grandma style were both delicious. Service was great as well, will be going back before leaving town for sure.

Really fantastic Pizza. We were very pleasantly surprised when we walked into this place. The staff and the atmosphere are great too. Excellent value, excellent pizza!

Great New York Pizza , just as good as what we get in Little Italy in Manhattan without the traffic and the waiting. Very highly recommend this if you are in the area.

Pizza was great. Staff made me feel at home even when it was my first time trying their pizza. Great environment and even better pizza. Can't wait to return.

The owner was great, very personable and welcoming. The pizza was some of the best I've ever had
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner

First time In NY and let me tell you this is the beat pizza I’ve ever eaten , highly recommended if your out of state and want some good pizza

Really fresh & delicious pizza. I love that the cheese is not too much, and the sauce is a good amount on there. Really good!

I tried their Grandma's pizza for the first time after ordering their normal pizzas for so long and I liked it just as much

Big pillowy sicilian. Crispy thin slices. Sauce, cheese, and pepperoni have little flavor. Reminds me of roller rink pizza.

This place is so dirty which I noticed right away. I started to look around and saw roaches, I was done never coming back

Pizza slice was delicious. Think it's the sauce...or the cheese. Both were flavorful. Friendly service. $3 for slice.

Good food, friendly staff and reasonable prices.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4

Just moved to the area, this pizza is my favorite so far. Good stuff!
Service
Take out

Brother’s is a staple in the neighborhood. Love their food and the owner Dennis is the man.

Top shelf, solid, old school NYC slice. Brothers Pizza in Flushing is a must visit!

Monday Special. Good folks, feels nice and old school for the area.

Amazing pizza! Loved their pizza and they're fries. To do