Every single time I order sauce on the side I never ever ever get it.. and I always ask twice because I don’t trust that they’ll give it and without fail I’ve never gotten my extra sauce that they charge me for. Honestly I let it go the first couple times but now it’s just kind of annoying. More

The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Every bite was a delight, and the ingredients tasted top-notch. If you're a pizza enthusiast, this place is definitely worth a visit for its outstanding food quality. Also has a fantastic Gluten-Free personal pie More

Wasn’t going post but 40$ down the trash. Absolutely disappointing…. That’s a chicken roll soaked, can’t even hold it had to eat it with fork and knife until I gave up and ordered again from Amici down the block. Personal pie that came with it also down the trash. SMH More

Ive been ordering here since I moved to the South Shore last year. Excellent food! Soooooooooo delicious!!! Whenever I call, the staff is polite and professional. The delivery always comes within a reasonable time. Definitely my "go to" spot!

Not bad for a quick slice, I wouldn't say its anything amazing but it was definitely good. Biggest complaint was the place is super small. A group of 5 or 6 people was there ordering when I walked in and took up pretty much the entire front

I've had food from Domenico's to varying degrees over the last decade. I specifically remember finding the place to be decent to lower quality. I specifically stopped going there in person when I got the hottest slices of my life. It was so

Ordered for the first time to try somewhere new. Disappointed with the sampler box. Was all 7/11 style put in and reheat stuff. Ordered the Neapolitan pizza. It wasn’t a Neapolitan. Was expecting pillowy soft charred dough and it was thin

It’s a shame that I go there as always on my break from the hospital. The girl even before I order told me that I have to wait 10m for a slice of pizza. There were all kind of pizzas in the counter and she told me that I had to wait and I

I was so excited to show my British husband NY pizza for the first time. We were visiting from out of town, and got him a decent slice in Manhattan. It just didnt feel EXACTLY like I remembered as a kid. My grandmother suggested here. We

Had no issue with the food itself, however they gave us a completely different order. When I called to complain they said they will send the driver back right away and I should meet him in the main lobby. After half an hour of waiting I

Pizza is fantastic and the hot heros are absolutely delicious. "The Domenico's Special" hero and the Chicken Francese hero are 2 of my favorites. Ingredients always taste fresh. Owner and staff are very polite and friendly and delivery

Their very expensive rice ball with meat was disgusting,expired and rotten! You can immediately taste the rancid spoiled meat and hard rice because it wasn’t fresh and been sitting on the shelf way too long! Honestly I couldn’t even

Usually my go to spot but last night I ordered late and ordered a pie since I got home late from work. Pie was a mess half of the cheese was on the side . It was probably an off night for them going to give it one more try. More

This is my first time ordering from here. I got the Eggplant arugula and peppers hot hero, my partner got the ham calzone...both are EXTREMELY delicious. The food was delivered faster than expected also. Highly recommend. More

We ordered 4 catered meals for 100 people each meal for the Tottenville marching band. The owner was wonderful to work with. He took care of us 100%. The food was delicious and we will continue ordering! More

The team at Domenico's is very well trained in cooking the best thin crust pizza in NYC. Domenico's Upside Down Pizza is Staten Island's best kept secret. Their sauces are grandma level *****.

Some of the best pizza and service I ever experienced. We get pizza from domenico almost every week. It’s a bit of drive from my place but very well worth it. More

Ordered through Grubhub. Arrived on time. Food was excellent. Pizza was cooked perfect. Vodka sauce was amazing!

Gentlemen that owns the place takes pride in his business and they have the best wings on Staten Island. More

This place is always excellent!! I order from here all of the time.