Honestly, SOMEONE HERE PLAYED A PRACTICAL JOKE ON US!!!! It’s not acceptable if you’re looking for flavor they really did good So 3-4 stars for flavor But the cake decorations literally look like I gave my 3 years finger paints and said have at it… there where places where it looks like someone dug their fingers in it!?!? Why ask me if I want the colors on the reference picture if they are going to add so many extra UGLY DISTASTEFUL COLORS?? I was so embarrassed of the cake that it sat in the fridge until time to cut and I was PRAYING that the flavor made up for this ULTRA Sad representation of what I asked. Please don’t say you can do something that CLEARLY HAVE NO BUSINESS ATTEMPTING AND THEN CHARGING THE PRICE …. I would have said I am so sorry we made a colossal mistake on the outside here’s how it looks we can do the outside maybe something more “simpler” hey would have been better at this point. Honestly I am scared to even order a custom cake again.. again flavor on the inside was good but I was SO DISAPPOINTED FOR PAYING EXTRA FOR THE DECORATIONS THAt we could have got it plain and honestly I could have done anything better than this :/ I do not recommend this place because they were not honest from the beginning, showed no remorse of respect of giving someone you know good and well it would not be up to ANYONES EXPECTATIONS

I live in NJ and order for my family in Texas. I have done this for several years. I ordered the 10 inch, $100 Symphony cake for my family. I spoke to 2 different people and told them I did NOT want the raspberry filling. My family HATES fruit flavored filling. I asked for the white chocolate mousse. Well… I picked up the cake and it looked beautiful. Nothing spectacular, but really nice! We cut into the cake for 4 family members’ birthdays, and what was inside??? Raspberry filling! I called the store to tell them to be more mindful of special orders, and the person who answered apologized and said she would have the owner call me. It has been a week, and I haven’t heard from anyone. I guess they really don’t care. Kroger might be a better place to order from. Their cakes are just as good and 1/4 the cost!

Wonderful ! A box of six cupcakes each was a different flavor perfect !!! Grandkids loves them . So happy to have found them ! Small cakes that was Nextdoor to my work has been gone for a while now so be sure and go here !
Service
Take out
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Cupcake

Had them make an Italian cream cake for my daughter's first birthday. Not only did the cake look amazing and exactly what I wanted, the taste was just as amazing! Also had some red velvet cupcakes and some strawberry cupcakes made at the same time that were also out of this world!! I will always come back to Elite Treats for any cake I need for any occasion. Great Job Guy's!!!!

Thank you so much for making my daughter’s birthday cake look absolutely amazing and tasting amazing! Y’all do such beautiful work and can’t wait to order more cakes in the future! The lemon filling is by far the best!!!!! Also thanks so much for my chicken cookies for my mother in laws Birthday she loves them and they were great! Thanks again!

Cakes I have bought all been yummy, beautiful, and my family is picky. We hate fondant and its wonderful to find a place that doesn't work with it. Yes it's a bit more pricey than other places but I don't buy cakes often, well not anymore. Just wish they stayed open a bit later, hard to make it before noon or if they delivered!!!!

We got a piece of Chocolate Mouse Cake at a birthday party. My husband really isn't a cake eater - but he tried a piece & said it's like Heaven! We got (2) pieces to take home & as soon as we got home - he ate another piece. I finally got a piece of cake today & he was right! It was like Heaven!

Best cake ever! We ordered a chocolate cake with peanut butter mousse and it tasted like Reese’s pieces! When you order a shaped or themed cake they usually look amazing but don’t taste all that great. Elites look and taste amazing! I highly recommend!

The absolute best bakery, the cakes are so moist, never too sweet and they have the best flavor. My family gets every cake from Elite Treats and have been for years! I don’t know how they do it but their cake is the best any of us have ever had.

Margie the owner went above the call of duty. Wonderful service. Sweet souls there no wonder they work with sweets . Hope you enjoy their company and treats as I did. Key lime cake .
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Elite Treats did a beautiful job with our wedding cake! We had three tiers including one that was gluten free. All were delicious and the overall cake was very pretty! They were able to make a custom design based on photos we found online

Horrible people! My son and I had a mixup of our credit cards and when he called to find out who used his card, they canceled my other sons wedding cake. They still had my original deposit and did not even bother to call and let me know

We ordered 4 dozen cupcakes for a birthday party. They were phenomenal! We ordered vanilla, red velvet, carrot cake and german chocolate. Each had a different flavor as filling. They were all delicious. The vanilla filled with a

They were able to put together a last minute order for our company party. Ordered a medium sheet cake and 6 dozen cupcakes. Everything was delicious and they even had a gluten-free cupcake option. More

Elite treats made my wifes b-day cake. They couldn't of done a better a job. The cake was great. We loved it. It tasted great, very satisfied. Definitely going to be a repeat customer.

Purchased cake for my mother’s 90th birthday. Had selected a custom marble with a raspberry filling. The cake was so moist and delicious! It went QUICK! I really enjoy their cakes!

Ordered the Black Forest cake. Sooooo delicious! It’s hard to find a bakery whose reviews match the taste. This one does! We will absolutely ONLY order from them from now on.

Their cakes are the best!!! I love them and it is my favorite bakery around!! Ryan is extremely helpful and there was great customer service!! 10/10

Cake was soooo good! It was exactly what I had asked for. I’ll be coming here for all my cakes.

Simply Amazing. The staff is very nice and the cakes are equally as good