This was the first time i ate here and i was a bit disappointed. I had high expectations after all the recommendations I got to eat here. Maybe it was a one off thing for you guys. First I ordered a creamy pesto pasta, a chicken lover pizza, and chicken wedges. Guess what the total was. 55$! I at least though the portion sizes would be reasonable for the overpriced food but I was completely wrong. The pasta was 17 dollars yet I got a box that was barely the size of a full plate. When I scooped the pasta on my plate, IT DIDN'T EVEN TAKE UP HALF THE PLATE. Next were the chicken wedges. A pack of 6 costed me 8 dollars so I expected something at least decent. Instead I got something that looked like it was frozen and just microwaved and put in a box. Seriously? Frozen food at a restaurant? Next was the pizza. Now the pizza was 24 dollars, so expected it to be some really good pizza that was better than fast food places. Guess what I got. The pizza was cold, hard and tasted worse than domino's. And domino's pizza only costs 8 dollars. The same for your chicken wedges. Now this sums up my review. Don't eat here unless you want to waste money on half decent overpriced food.
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$40–60

The Absolute Master Chefs of Pizza...!!! Their Pizzas are second to none, and an explosion of flavours that satisfy every single tastebud...!!! So wonderful to have a family business still consistently delivering benchmark quality coupled with great old fashioned country service with positivity, love and smiles...!!! Simply Brilliant...!!! It exceeded all our expectations, so flavourful, nothing short of perfect. I wanted to take a photo but we literally couldn't stop eating once we started. The amount given to us was true "family sized/style" as we had enough to take home with us. It is so amazing to know that you can still go to a restaurant and be treated like family from the moment you enter all the way through to the time you leave. Treated with the level of care and attention that stops you from leaving, and also wanting to come back every lunch or night. Nothing is ever an issue or problem - At Goodfellas Pizzeria Blacktown, they consistently Deliver Happiness with every meal - thank you so very much...!!!

I was excited to try Goodfellas Pizzeria, but unfortunately, I was left disappointed. While the pizza was good, it wasn't great. The crust was decent, but the toppings were lackluster, and the sauce was too sweet for my liking. I ordered a pasta dish as well, and it was overcooked and not very flavorful. Overall, the food was mediocre at best, and I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here again. In terms of service, the staff was friendly, but the wait time for my food was longer than expected. The restaurant itself was clean and cozy, but the seating was uncomfortable. The prices were reasonable, but for the quality of the food, I expected better. If you're in the area and want a quick bite, this place might be worth a visit, but don't expect a five-star experience.

Pizza we ordered was great. The base was crunchy but not burnt. Flavour was spot on. We couldn’t say the same for their pasta though. It was underwhelming, a rip-off even. The pasta sauce wasn’t cooked, it tasted like it came straight out of a bottle and the noodles soggy. ‘ Wouldn’t recommend ordering their pasta. From what I have observed at the shop and online reviews, most patrons have high praises for their Indian Pizzas. I have yet to try one but it must be spectacular considering that the shop drew in big crowds on a weekday evening trade. I hope they re-evaluate their menu though and remove items that they know shouldn’t be there (hint, hint).
Meal type
Dinner
Food: 3
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 3

We were lucky enough to have Steve and the team as live caterers during our event. Everyone was absolutely blown away with the food and impressive service. Steve made sure the entire crowd was well fed and ensured everyone’s dietary requirements were well cared for. Communication was impeccable and I cannot stress how easy it was to have everything organised. The team arrived exactly as communicated and food was served straight away. Upon packup - not one piece of rubbish was left behind. Everything was swiftly packed. We will definitely recommend Steve and the team again for all our future events.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

The hidden gems you stumble across. Very rare so you find quality takeaway food for a reasonable price. Was very hesitate to try the Indian Style pizzas at first. However I'm glad i did. The mouthful of flavour in one pizzas was absolutely amazing. Had the Tandoori Pineapple would highly recommend for those vegetarian enthusiast.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–20
Recommendation for vegetarians
Highly recommend
Vegetarian offerings
Large vegetarian selection
Vegetarian options
Large variety of Indian Style Pizzas

That sounds delicious! Indian-style pizza and pasta can be a unique and flavorful experience. It's great to hear that the ingredients are always fresh and that there's a wide variety of options to choose from. When it comes to pizza, Indian-style toppings can include things like paneer, tandoori chicken, and various spices and herbs. It's always a good idea to support restaurants that prioritize fresh ingredients and offer a wide variety of dishes. Enjoy your pizza and pasta!
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$20–40

We have never eaten or seen such a majestic garlic bread, it was glistening in holy deliciousnesses. The pizza was amazing and the pasta was top tier.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Tandoori, Chicken 65, Pollo Peri Peri, Garlic Bread, Garlic, Chilli Paneer Pizza, Harabhara Pizza
Vegetarian options
We have never eaten such good vegetarian items, this place is a must for a good meal at a bargain price.

The pizza was not that great in taste. Pasta was also ok ok. We paid extra for the extra cheese, and explicitly mentioned for adding extra cheese, still we received the regular option pizza only. Mad toppings, Montys pizzas does better pizzas than this. Completely disappointed. Not worth driving so far from far away places to here. But, it can be a good option for local residents if required.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$20–40
Food: 2
Service: 2
Atmosphere: 2

We ordered from Goodfellas in the past multiple times and pizzas were awesome. But tonight when we ordered Panner Angara and Veg Manchurian, both pizzas are tasteless, Panner angara had three chillies spiciness but today it was so mind that even young children can eat without sweating. I should not say but inflation is really hitting our pockets. You lost my business Goodfellas.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$40–60
Food: 2
Service: 2
Atmosphere: 2

OMG, what is going on with this place? Used to be great pizzas, then place was sold & now the pizzas are hit & miss. The pizza crust is so thin that it doesn’t even hold the toppings - not that there is much anyway. The 2 female staff that were working tonight were busy arguing with each other. Several orders were wrong, or were incorrect with items missing. I wouldn’t recommend this place.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Food: 1
Service: 1

I was hoping the pizzas would be comparable to other pizza shops in blacktown, but unfortunately I was very disappointed. The pizza base looked and tasted like a mass produced product bought from a Coles or Woolies freezer, thin and bland. It was also over cooked. The pizzas also look nothing like the menu photos. Only positive was they were cheaper so I didn't waste as much money.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–20

Really nice place. I would go again. The only improvements I would suggest are that they have tables which cater for larger groups coming to eat and maybe next time serve the food with plates rather than eat directly from the wooden board.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Food: 4
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Samosa Pizza
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot

Tried it for the first time .... The pepperoni pizza is probably the most disgusting thing I have ever tasted in my life and had a bad smell to it. Bought another pizza, not sure what the name is. This was edible but not worth paying for. Very disappointed with this purchase.
Service
Delivery
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$20–40
Food: 1
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 1

- overhyped indian pizza - pizza is thincrust - over-baked and hence soggy/ hard to chew - taste is very subpar - panneer tikka pizza and shahi panner pizza both had less panneer and veggies on it - pesto bites are hard as dog biscuits
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$20–40
Food: 2
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 3
Vegetarian options
Not worth it.

Attendant did not know how to split payment between two cards, and was going to charge extra if we paid separately. Price of the pizzas went astronomically high after adjustments were made. The pizzas made us feel sick that night experiencing bloating, gas and upset digestive systems. Definitely won't be going back!
Food: 1
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 2

2 stars only for Nice samosa pizza. Dine in there but didn’t find any good service. Not even basic things like Tissues or any sauce bottles etc. you need to ask for that. long wait. Make sure you order at once.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$20–40
Recommended dishes
Veg Manchurian Pizza, Garlic Bread, Paneer Angara Pizza

I thought there’d be more to a “Nutella pizza” like some strawberries or bananas or even white chocolate drizzle. Nothing… I scroll through the reviews and see one with strawberries and banana on their Nutella pizza. I’m disappointed. $12 for basically nutella toast. I’m actually so disappointed because my first experience with them was delicious.

We ordered a seafood prawn pizza and chicken tikka pizza. Both were perfectly cooked, crispy with fresh toppings and not just flooded with cheese as you see in other shops. The lady was very helpful with her suggestions and cooked them to perfection. We would love to go there again to try some of the other pizzas.

Ordered 6 Pizzas last night - normally very enjoyable. Unfortunately most were smothered in TOO MUCH Mushroom. We all like Mushroom but that was all you could see and taste. Pretty disappointed. Mushroom killed taste of everything else. Fantastic if you LOVE Mushrooms. But TOO many mushrooms.

Most amazing atmosphere with amazing service! And most importantly I love a unique cuisine momo pizza! Its really savoury and delicious with great taste! Its a must try if you are visiting goodfellas! Good fellas is a great choice!!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Called the Goodfellas pizzeria, they didn't explain the deals properly for 3 medium pizza. The first thing they should say that it would cost less and we would get a drink and garlic bread free. The deals are not explained over the phone properly. Please work on explaining the deals.

Good dine in place. They have Italian style pizzas and Indian style pizzas. Customer service was really good. They have given us good suggestions for spicy pizzas. Overall nice and clean place, good pictures and delicious pizzas
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner

Amazing pizza very yummy and delicious .Very good customer service . Every slice of pizza give wonderful taste with every bite. I always come here for dining and suggest to everyone come here and try the wonderful pizzas .
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner

Their live catering service is very professional and has really great options, and they went above and beyond and made us different pizzas in addition to the ones that had requested. Great value for money and could not recommend enough. Will definitely be back again.

This place has delicious vegetarian Pizza. We have tried Samosa pizza, Schezwan paneer and vege lovers. All 3 are tempting and Garlic breads are also very tasty.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Ordered for pick up through their website at 12:10 for my sisters engagement party. Showed up at 12 and the shop was closed with no one inside. No one was answering the phone or responding to Facebook messages. Waited until 12:15 and left. More

Not happy. I ordered 3 Nutella pizzas from this store based on the picture on there website. A Nutella pizza with Banna and strawberrys. What did I get. 3 Nutella pizzas with just that on them. Nutella. Nothing else. Called the store to ask

This is my first ever food review I’ve done and to be honest. Worst meal I have ever received. 2x cold and dry pizzas, king prawn pasta with not even 1 single king prawn, 6 of the smallest and driest wings I have ever seen. For example see

Worst pizza I have ever tried by far. The base was so thin it was like dorito chips. The sauce tasted as if it were bought from the shops. There were no toppings, the only topping that was visible was coriander and I for sure did not buy

Amazing pizzas and excellent service ! Samosa Pizza, Vadapao pizza & Chef Special Pasta were highlight of today’s dinner ! Thank you Team Good Fellas !
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Normally get Dominos cos it's usually cheap and quick but they've raised the prices so looked somewhere else. Ended up getting better tasting pizzas quicker and cheaper from Goodfellas. More

Waited for 1 hour and We ordered harabhra paneer pizza without paneer, she charges extra for removing paneer. And it was not fresh at all. Always Short staffed !!

Last time I had vadapav pizza , it was totally worth it to make time to go there and value of money.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

I give this a 4 star not only for the taste but the different Indian flavour options. Indian flavours do go on pizza I will be back …

One of the best pizza in town, Traditional Pizza is must try, worth every $$, amazing food, amazing staff and great ambience.. #must_try

Very poor service. Don't answer the phone. The woman at the counter can't take orders Waiting a hour. So the pizza better be dam good

Very unique pizza authentic Indian test. unbelievable Indian people love it. food. really great effort and maintain test.

Their service is quite fast and pizza r very delicious like paneer Tikka pizza , hara bhara pizza .

Got one large pizza, Hara bhara without paneer Asked for tomato and corns instead,