Picky Barista

312 reviews

2680 Broadway, New York, NY 10025

www.pickybarista.com

+16466843037

About

Picky Barista is a Coffee shop located at 2680 Broadway, New York, NY 10025. It has received 312 reviews with an average rating of 4.5 stars.

Photos

Hours

Monday7AM-6PM
Tuesday7AM-6PM
Wednesday8AM-6PM
Thursday8AM-6PM
Friday7AM-6PM
Saturday7AM-6PM
Sunday7AM-6PM

F.A.Q

Frequently Asked Questions

  • The address of Picky Barista: 2680 Broadway, New York, NY 10025

  • Picky Barista has 4.5 stars from 312 reviews

  • Coffee shop

  • "Cozy little coffee shop on Broadway and 1 102nd St"

    "In a sea of terrible NYC coffee, at least these guys serve Stumptown"

    "Cute little spot with tasty homemade pastries"

    "Interesting name and concept of peaky that u can see some hats hanging on the wall"

    "Delicious Americano in a cosy, friendly space"

Reviews

  • Damien Bassman

Cozy little coffee shop on Broadway and 1 102nd St. This is a great spot to sit and read a book while having a cuppa tea or share some cookies with friends chatting over coffee. Servers are friendly and prices are reasonable. I only gave four stars for the food because they only had one vegan option in the entire display case. More

  • Karla Mei Robertson

In a sea of terrible NYC coffee, at least these guys serve Stumptown. I wish there was a pour over option, but I ended up going with a drip and a cappuccino. Not the best renditions of Stumptown beans- the drip was particularly weak. But at least I could taste the fruity notes of the beans. More

  • Arri

Cute little spot with tasty homemade pastries. I got their drip coffee and my partner got an espresso and both are delicious. My drip coffee was smooth and strong and not too acidic. They have post milk and accept tap to pay, too. I tried their baklava which was a nice nosh. More

  • Oscar Liu

Interesting name and concept of peaky that u can see some hats hanging on the wall. The coffee is relatively dark roasted, not bad but not my thing. The Baklava from Turkey tastes nice, sweet and moist. Overall vibe is quite chill for a brief stay More

  • Lauren Wallett Media

Delicious Americano in a cosy, friendly space. I love the different seating options. We sat at the window and then at the back on the yellow couch with a heater behind us (so warm and great). They have wifi and I appreciated the sign saying

  • Venu Santhakumar

Coffee is amazing, and I was coming here every day I was in the area. The vibe is great and a nice place to work Monday to Friday. Unfortunately, stay away from the pastries. They were old and stale, after one bite we couldn't keep eating

  • Jacqui Knight

This cafe is beautiful inside, love the exposed brick wall and long table. Unfortunately the coffee was not good, it was very weak (could barely taste coffee at all) and the milk was overheated. The chai tasted watered down. We also got a

  • DUMPEL DUMPEL

This place was discovered smack dab in the middle of COVID by me and my then BF a coffeeman in his own right. Now ever since I have discovered latte with heavy cream, nothing else seems good enough. This place managed to nudge me back to

  • Jason Olliff

I was excited to check this place out as it looked nice from outside, but I was very let down. The coffee was cold and not what I ordered. The staff were particularly rude; one lady specifically, I think the owner. There was a hair in my

  • Jerald Kaplan

Great local coffee shop location on 102nd and Broadway! Matcha and tumeric lattes are delicious and well made without any added sugars. Balkan coffee packs a punch and is delicious. I had the Nutella Roll, highly recommended! All of the

  • alicia y

Drip coffee black was smooth but a bit too acidic. The two pastries I got (one was Nutella the other had some type of jam inside) weren’t great. Rather than being light and buttery or dense and moist, they were simply heavy, doughy, and

  • Katie Cascone

Coffee was a 3/5, very light. The slice of flakey quiche I had was bland and so saturated in oil I regretted eating it later, feeling kinda sick all morning. Atmosphere was a great spot to meet for coffee, but they chose the chairs for

  • Crash Buist

I gave this place an extra star because the staff is so nice. But... the food and coffee was so bad that I can't in good conscience suggest anyone visit. We had two lattes that tasted like they were made with expired soy milk, and the

  • Victoria Washington

This spot is confused on what it wants to be. Peaky blinders inspired with white brick, Native American art, and Spanish music. All of those elements are wonderful on their own, but together seem perplexing. Came in at 12 pm and the

  • William Viquez

I stopped here after Capoeira. Really nice atmosphere, chill vibes and it is a place I where would love to sit down and read. The coffee was good, I got a cold brew. Hope to come back and try something else. Recommended. More

  • Maryam Gani

i love this place! every time i've gone, i've been able to find a place to sit and work which i'm so happy about. the espresso is delicious and rich which is something that's important to me. super cute and picturesque cafe.

  • Drago Galich

This charming coffee shop tucked away in the bustling streets of NYC, has quickly become my favorite spot for a delightful caffeine fix. What sets this place apart is not just the quality of their coffee but the

  • Noy Saar Zylberman

Roberta was amazing! She was kind, and went out of the way to make my experience at picky barista the best possible. The coffee was excellent, and I highly recommend the Nutella roll which was delicious! More

  • Christie Porter

Very cute decor. Ample seating. Nice music. Great amount of light from the windows. Tasty chai latte. WiFi is spectrum WiFi and only free for 30 minutes, so keep that in mind if you need it.

  • Laura Montoya

Employee made no eye contact with me and was interested in continuing her conversation with her colleague. And on top of that, gave me a look of disdain when I didn’t tip her. More

  • L M

I love this place for a delicious and relaxing cup of coffee. It's small but cozy. You won't stay long, but the stay will be nice and welcoming. Great vibe. More

  • Katherine Morales Lugo

This is my regular place, the coffee is pretty good although I am not a huge fan of the pastries. It is the atmosphere that really does it for me though :) More

  • Spiros Pagiatis

I had a very nice cappuccino. A REAL ONE. The steamed milk was at the right temperature. Definitely I will go back any time I find myself in the area. More

  • Keya Ghonasgi

Food was average. They don't have a kitchen, so they only have premade food like croissants. The other Peaky Barista nearby has better food options. More

  • Vanessa Diaz

Super cute and nice working space but limited outlets so make sure you have charged laptops Con: no bathroom but bathroom nearby at bagel shop

  • Paloma Camelo

The Capuccino is amazing! Loved this atmosphere, very chill. Perfect for an afternoon study-time or just to get a coffee with a friend. More

  • Rob Vucinic

Best coffee shop in the Upper West Side. Peaky Barista ranks 5/5 on everything you need from a local coffee shop.

  • Drew Mizer Helton

Delicious and friendly. The selection of bakery items are also so delicious. I love this place!
Meal …
More

  • Grace Lee

Local vibes. Using coffee beans from Stumptown. I got a cappuccino with almond milk. Taste good.
Serv…
More

  • Ticha Ungboriboonpisal

Great coffee around Columbia. Small and cute setting. No restroom or wifi so I cannot linger here for long. More

  • Iulian B

Peaky barista is one of my favorite places when it comes to a nice expresso in Manhattan
Service…
More

  • Anh Tran

Love the atmosphere and coffee! Easy enough to find a seat to do work and the staff is very friendly. More

  • Anastasiia Yamelynets

Very cute, vibey coffee shop. Staff are very nice. Also love the “no laptop” policy.
Service…
More

  • Joan Manuel Lezcano

Very beautiful place. The coffee was delicious! But the attention is a bit bad.
Service…
More

  • Nadav Regev

The barista Roberta is very nice. Great macha and the atmosphere is cozy
Food: 5…
More

  • Marissa Lanoff

New favorite spot! The most delicious latte I’ve had in a long time!
Meal type…
More

  • kote bernal

Great coffee and location. A hidden gem for sure!
Service
Dine in…
More

  • Proietti Marco

Awesome coffee, cozy environment, nice music. The perfect local cafeteria.

  • brandon basso

The coffee is really good!! But the muffin didn’t taste so fresh.

  • Shera Raisen

Love my tumeric latte!
Service
Dine in…
More

Similar places

Starbucks

1796 reviews

157-41 Cross Bay Blvd, Howard Beach, NY 11414

Starbucks

1206 reviews

61-51 188th St, Queens, NY 11365

Starbucks

1112 reviews

1417 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11229

Starbucks

1110 reviews

78-25 37th Ave, Queens, NY 11372

Starbucks

1104 reviews

8900 Sutphin Blvd, Queens, NY 11435

Bluestone Lane Upper East Side Café

1049 reviews

1085 5th Ave, New York, NY 10128

Starbucks

1045 reviews

346 Baychester Ave, Bronx, NY 10475

787 Coffee

920 reviews

66 Pearl St, New York, NY 10004

Dunkin'

880 reviews

13320 Rockaway Blvd, Queens, NY 11420

% Arabica

805 reviews

20 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201