My mate and I went on the 9th of December. We were there later in the evening, after midnight. It was quite busy for being late, but didn't have a long wait to get a drink. My mate ordered a Bailey's on ice, which he was told they didn't have. So the bartender said he would make something similar. He came back with Brandy Alexander's. Except for the cream, they are not similar. But it's the thought that counts. The drink was not my cup of tea, but that is not the bartenders fault. I ordered a coupon beers but told the bartender it was his choice on what beers he brings back. I can tell you that the bartender is not a beer drinker . Again, not the fault of the bartender. I have no review of the food, as we did not have any nor do I even know if they serve food here. On another note, while my mate and I waited in queue to get in, we let these two women ahead of us, as I believe one said it was her birthday. A few moments later, the birthday girl got in to a kerfuffle with the doorman as she felt the door man got a little handsy with her. While she and the doorman discussed the incident, The other woman and I started chatting for a fair bit and we seemed to hit it off. Then we (my mate and I) were pulled aside and led downstairs, by the manager I assume, and asked what we saw. It was really just an eager girl going in a bit early and an overzealous door man. By the time we were finished with the manager, the two girls had left. Anyways, the woman I was chatting to seemed to be incredibly cool, incredibly beautiful and quite funny as well. In my stupidity, I never asked her for her number, as I was a bit distracted by her friends conversation, and maybe a bit mesmerized. Then when I thought to, it was a bit too late! I am hoping that she, one of her friends, or an acquaintance that has heard this story from her, may read this and relay this back so I that I may get in contact with her.
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 4

To get to this bar you first walk through a dimly lit tunnel road opening up to a club of four or five different bars. On the right you would find a rather underwhelming stairway taking you to The Baxter Inn bar. Once inside you would be taken back to one of those bars that are shown in classic retro movies from the early 1900’s. The place itself has a old worldly exquisite feel and boasts an unmatchable collection of more than 300 rare and exclusive whiskies. The staff are thoroughly professional that take the time to explain the menu and also offer a bowl of free pretzels. I had the Ventura while my wife had the Baba (tall glass in the picture). Both cocktails were lip smackingly delicious and I can’t wait to visit this hidden gem again soon! The Baxter Inn - You have won our hearts!

Had the best best best night at the Baxter Inn!! Leah was especially amazing, making us amazing cocktail after amazing cocktail. We asked her to make us whatever cocktails she wanted to and she definitely did not disappoint! Would 1000000% recommend people to come here on a Tuesday night to witness Leah’s amazing skills and creations x
Price per person
$20–40
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Dalwhinnie, Whiskey Chamber, Pretzels, Duvel, Nibbles, Whiskey Glenfarclas 21, Oban Distillers, Pilsner, Lime Burners Directors Cut, Sriracha, Ledaig Bordeaux, Bolovino Pinot Grigio, Nikka Pure Malt Red, Whistle Pig Farm, Bruichladdich Scotch Barley, French Cask, Laphroaig Quarter, Oban 14, Num Nums, Laphroaig Port Wood

After working in Sydney for more than 10 years never knew about this place until yesterday.. what a unique and weird place. The entrance is just a back door and you go down into a basement. Then you see the largest collection of whiskey and alcohol that I have ever seen. Some of the whiskey that we tasted was very good. The bartenders know what they are doing. Simply say what you want or let them decide if you explain the preferences. The whiskey shots range from about $15 upwards to more than $800..! If whiskey is what you like definitely check this place out. Be prepared to spend big.. The experience itself is awesome. Don’t forget if you are going here don’t drive.. as you will come out a bit fresh..

Hands down, still the best whiskey bar in Sydney. I always opt to sit at the bar, so I can get the recommendations from the knowledgeable bar staff. It always amazes me how much they know, remember and hit the mark with their suggestions. The selection on offer is enormous and I always end up getting to sample whiskeys that are tasty and won't find in your local Dan Murphy's store. But they do those as well, if you are looking for it. My best experience has always been to sample scotches from the various regions in Scotland. It always makes for a great night. Keep up the excellent work team.
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

WATCH as he puts the cherry down my orange peel? Baxter's has been on my list for a while and on a night out we didn't see a queue so we took the plunge. It's a great place to spend some money on delicious drinks! Seriously some of these drinks were so easy to drink and it was fun trying the different cocktails. They offer negroni on tap and of course memories of blackout night followed The menu was pizza from Frankies and since it's now shut I'm not sure what they'll do for food. However they do offer free nibbles. Hope that's enough All in all very nice venue.

The nostalgia of having to walk into a dark laneway and then down and back entrance to a basement to find an Old Style whisky Bar was like walking back in time! Sitting at the Bar you get overwhelmed by the selection of whisky on display! And the continuous cocktail making performance was entertainment enough for anyone looking for a good night out! Only found this place due to the lack of venue opening at late hours on a weekday, and this place open till 3am!
Price per person
$20–40
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pretzels

Really good whisky bar with an amazing selection of whiskys from around the world. Staff know their stuff and are friendly and it's great to see them pouring the drinks and climbing on ladders to find stuff. The whisky cocktails are great too. Underground, secret bar with an entrance down a fire escape in a back alley off the main street. The candles seem to have been dripping wax for years but it looks great. There's some space to sit depending on how busy it is. Early in the evening is great if you want a quiet time at the bar with a mate, they'll give you free pretzels too.

This is an underground powerhouse that transformed me into a whiskey drinker. Try their whiskey sour or the old fashioned and you'll never go back! The Baxter Inn has fantastic staff who smile and look after you all night. The venue is wonderfully "hidden" with a dark, moody atmosphere. Beautiful horse portraits and boxing legend photos frame the walls to create an old town, American vibe. You'll get free pretzels here to snack on, yay! This place is incredible and set the bar so high I didn't want to review it (I hate queues). Thanks to the team at this establishment.

One of the best bars in Sydney if not one of the best bars I have ever been to. I give this high score mostly for the staff there. The bartenders know their craft very well, and must be perfectly trained. The selection of whisky is fantastic. They also have an amazing Sauvignon Blanc if that's your vibe. The bartenders focus on personalized approach- they will tell more more about the drink you are having, entertain you by conversation when needed and just make your visit better. I'd recommend to sit at the bar.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

I really struggled here, the lighting was super dark. The candle light and the massive wax structures under the candles looked cool and made the place feel fairly gothic, but the gold lettering on the wall of drinks was impossible for me to read. Looked cool, not practical. So I largely have no idea what I was drinking from their (quite large) selection of whiskeys. There was a cloudy apple cocktail I tried that was delicious too. The drinks were good, the lights were not to my taste.
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4

Wow! What an amazing bar! Excellent bartenders slinging out creative and traditional cocktails with an impressive selection of whiskey and gin. Cool speakeasy vibes, feels like walking into the Great Gatsby novel. Drinks start at about 25$ so the tab could easily get away from you, but worth it! If you are looking for something special this is the place. It’s down an alley in an unmarked location but across from the Duke of Clarence signs. I’m highly critical of cocktails but I have no notes for this bar!

While the cost of drinks may be high, I can say that the knowledge and quality of staff interactions far exceed the expectations set by other established pubs in Sydney. I unfortunately didn't reserve a table, so I was unable to order food, but they were accommodating enough to allow bar seating. If you're looking for a premium whiskey experience where on and off menu drinks are offered, then this is the place to visit.
Price per person
$20–40
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

A great bar, not just for whiskey. A cool hidden gem in the city. The entrance is a bit dodgy down a fire stairwell but the vibe is great and it was open late for a Thursday until 3am before the last bell rang for drinks. Can take a while to get drinks at the bar when really busy so make sure you have friends already at a table waiting. They do manage capacity so you may have to line up for a while.
Price per person
$80–100
Food: 4
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5

Absolutely loved this place. Even though I'm not a whisky drinker. The atmosphere is like you've taken a step back in time. You'll find yourself walking down a dodgy alley way, to then make your way down some dodgy stairs to find this amazing bar. It is definitely worth checking out if you're in Sydney. The cocktails are amazing. The staff are super friendly and welcoming. You get mini pretzels at your table. And there is a massive range of whisky/scotch drinks to choose from.

Absolutely loved this whisky bar. It’s hidden in a narrow alley way and underground, so make sure you find the right place first. Drinks are not limited to the ones on the menu, so talk to the bar attendant about what you like, they really know how to make cocktails. I had two different whiskey based espresso cocktails, neither of them are on the menu and both are delicious. The same with whiskeys. If you don’t have specific requirements, ask and you will get what you want.

Intimate whisky bar right in the heart of Sydney. The atmosphere is classy, and the drinks are super refined. Old fashioned was one of the best I've had. Whisky selection is comprehensive. Beer selection has some interesting drops which was a pleasant surprise. Service was impeccable, the barstaff were friendly and patient, even though we went during the most busy time on a Saturday night. Free pretzels which are definitely appreciated. Absolutely highly recommended!

Was enjoying the bar too much that we forgot to take photos of the drinks! Great vibes and service, couldn't give 5 stars for Atmosphere due to the noise level but I guess it's understandable due to how popular this place is~ There is a HUGE variety of drinks and their signature cocktails are also GREAT. Be prepared to queue up though~
Price per person
$40–60
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Recommended dishes
Pretzels

The best whiskey bar in a speakeasy fashion. I love whiskey and this bar had more selection of whiskey than I have ever seen. The staff is very knowledgeable about the hundreds of products. A hidden gem open 7 days a week from 4 pm until 3 am. Also a good wine selection that my wife enjoyed. If you get to one bar in Sydney, this should be it. You won't be disappointed.
Price per person
$40–60
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Must go spot in Sydney and not just for whiskey lovers. Multiple options for non whiskey drinkers but for myself the best whiskey sour and old fashions I’ve ever had. Even bottomless ordinary pretzels seem like the greatest treat. Atmosphere is always amazing and the bartenders are by far the greatest.
Price per person
$40–60
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Whiskey Chamber, Pretzels

What a spot!! Highly recommend!! The vibes are immaculate and the drinks are top notch. Entering through a dark alley way and heading down steep stairs to reach a hidden world of lively bartenders shaking cocktails and ringing bells!! Complimentary pretzels are also given to everyone! There can be a wait sometimes but it’s worth it!
Price per person
$20–40
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pretzels

Have been a few times and always met with great service and atmosphere except for last night. The barman serving was disengaged and made me, my wife and friends feel like we were inconveniencing him. My friends were from out of state and after I had talked so highly of Baxter's I felt embarrassed in front of them. The end result was we had one drink and left.
Price per person
$20–40
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 5

Still one of my favourite bars in Sydney. Super friendly and attentive staff with good knowledge of whiskies. The complimentary pretzels are yummy and the music and vibe is great. Love that the music is at a level where you can still chat without screaming and it really adds to the atmosphere.
Price per person
$20–40
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pretzels, Local Whiskey

Very busy place which is understandable because of the awesome vibes. Hard to get a seat but when you do, it’s very chilled out. Whiskey collection is huge but prices are average. Visited the joint on a Wednesday around 10pm and it was quieter. The professional bar tender took us for a tour into there cellar, very nice gesture. My clients enjoyed it. Definitely will be back for more !

Down the stairs at the back of Barber s Shop, The Baxter Inn has a nice vibe and pumping music. I recommend to come a little earlier, so you can get a seat. Unfortunate that some of the mid range whisky isn't in stock (3 of 4 that I tried to order), however the bar tender was able to recommend alternatives. It is a bit loud in here, but you get a good feel of a good old bar vibe.

Are you enthusiastic and passionate about whisky? If the answer is yes, you definitely need to visit this place, I think they have more than 500 whisky around the world, which probably could be more. It's a hidden bar in the heart of cbd, nice music, and nice pretzel snacks.
Price per person
$20–40
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pretzels

The suberb whisky selection, blues prohibition speakeasy vibe, hidden in a backlane basement is just perfect. Hardworking, friendly bartenders make this a place worth visiting. Enjoy. Oh, the 5-star food rating is based purely on the Arbeg Perpetuum and Lagavulin 11. Both are gems.
Price per person
$20–40
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Really cool speakeasy bar in Sydney ‍♀️ i love how it was soooooo speakeasy - located in the basement of a building at the back of an alleyway! Worth a go! Yes the queue was so long but the ‘turnover rate’ is also really high- we only waited for like 10-15 mins on a Friday night
Food: 4
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5

The whiskey bar I always visit, even on my birthday. Bartenders are always nice and helpful. The only pity is they don’t take reservations due to their crowded bar all the time! I always take more than 5 rounds there hahah!!!
Price per person
$40–60
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pretzels

Must go to place in Sydney. I have never been to a place with as much whiskey. They have a bible and they know their history. I pretty much had a whiskey tasting your of Australia and the prices are reasonable and visible. Glenn and Glynn were both exceptional. Thanks again.
Price per person
$60–80
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

You wouldn’t expect much from the entrance, but once you’re in you find yourself in a speak easy bar. The atmosphere is great, staff friendly and helpful with recommendations and there is a lot of variety to choose from if you’re into whisky! Would recommend to go with friends to catch up with a nice drink and comfortable atmosphere.

Hot dang, just walked into (actually struggled to find the entrance) of one of the good bars in Sydney. Hands down great pretzels, great cocktails (try the Hollywood & Vine if you may) and great service (Hayden & Finlay are the MVPs). Gotta keep coming back and back.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

WHISKEY jsjdjd kxtyid WHISKY Mmmm kdjhrew PRETZELS! They know their stuff, but too many tourists for a serous Whiskey Bar. A special night out for a hangover you can treasure forever. I’ll be back!!
Price per person
$180–200
Food: 3
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 4
Recommended dishes
Pretzels

Words could not explain how amazing our experience here was I wouldn't want to either because everyone should experience this place for themselves Treat yourself!.. if you can find it
Price per person
$80–100
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pretzels

We had such a wonderful night out in this gem of a place with Peaky Blinders vibes. The eerie alleyway leading to the nondescript stairs down to the entrance added to the noir film ambience. Free flow yummy mini pretzels complemented the lovely cocktails as we soaked in the bustling yet cosy atmosphere.

Must go! Well known yet tucked away in the corner of an inner alley and guarded by a friendly bouncer, with a vast selection of scotches, whiskeys, delicious signature cocktails and old time blues tunes. True library just for spirits!
Price per person
$20–40
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Top notch cocktails with great services from bartender. However, overcapacity, tables ain’t cleaned let alone filthy toilet. Surely they are so proud of their selections of whiskies and beverages but could have more staff to look after other areas.
Food: 4
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 1

This place is iconic bringing a very special vibe. We love every single drink the bartender recommended for us including the amazing cocktails on the menu. My fav is ventura and headlights . We will be back
Price per person
$80–100
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Awesome bar for an after work drink. The big sell is their huge collection of whiskeys from all over the world. Get in early as the place gets packed really quickly. The only downside is the humidity in the place sometimes can leave you sweating at times. Other than it's a fantastic bar to check out

Celebrating our anniversary here since this is where we went in our first date. Big big shoutout to James who took care of us and absolutely passionate to what he’s doing. Keep up the hard work, legend!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pretzels

Enter through an alleyway, down 2 flights of stairs you will find this underground hidden gem. All cocktails made by the bartender were a delight, try to get a seat at the bar to watch the action. Music wasn’t unnecessary loud… really high classy, great vibes!
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Love this bar! We came here on a weekday afternoon. The selection of cocktails and whiskey is fantastic. Quite expensive, but worth it in my opinion. Free pretzels are a nice touch. The staff were all really friendly.
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pretzels

~960 whiskies; you won't run out. Great vibe, great to hang out with a bunch of mates. Music isn't too loud, fairly easy to have a conversation. To locate this place, go down an alleyway, then turn right and it's down a spiral of stairs. Worth it!
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

10/10 would recommend!!!!! I LOVE out of the way bars, especially ones that serve whisky. Amazing range of whisky and even more talented staff that know their stuff. It's a small capacity bar so get in early or you need to line up and wait..... But the wait is definitely worth it.

Amazing experience of a speakeasy bar with some amazing cocktails. Ordered an old fashioned and they killed it worth the money but most importantly the ambiance and lighting was worth it. Had a good time away from hustle bustle of city. Finding it was a bit of a task …

You want a speak easy, you got one. Didnt eat a thing, but tried a few whiskeys. Right on atmosphere, pro bartenders, more whiskey selections than a lifetime has room for. Plenty busy by 8.
Price per person
$60–80
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Parking
Ha

I love the atmosphere and how cozy this little bar is. We had wiskey sour, which was quite good. but it was smelling like sewage there which was a bit disturbing and we couldn't stay for long. I was a bit disappointed for the bar which is quite expensive to smell like that !

Sydney's ultimate hidden speakeasy whisky bar. A fairly limited but impressive selection of whiskies served by knowledgeable staff in a wonderful underground atmosphere. Never disappoints.
Price per person
$80–100
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Hidden treasure, Baxter never fails to impress if you need to show off Sydney's life to someone from interstate. Great bar with excellent choice of good whisky. They also make excellent cocktails. Nice lively athmosphere, good old rock and roll, great service, fantastic!

Outstanding underground whisky bar! If you're a whisky enthusiast seeking an extensive selection, The Baxter Inn in Sydney is the ultimate destination. The staff's expertise, warmth, and enthusiasm add an extra layer of delight to the already fantastic experience. More

Best bar in Sydney!! The vibes are immaculate and make you feel like you travel in time. Amazing drinks, live music was breathtaking and the pretzels you get are soo delicious! Best place.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Nice late night bar in a city that's hard to find anything good after 12am on a weekday. Amazing cocktails, exceptional service. Will visit again on my next trip to Sydney
Price per person
$40–60
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

I love this speak easy whisky bar, the selections are amazing and the staff really know their range, so don't think twice about getting some recommendations. There are free pretzels flowing but not much else on offer to eat. This is the pre

Very special place in the city of Sydney, despite the entrance to this place but that is what makes it unique and exclusive. Little known to people who are not from Sydney but I think that little by little it is on the agenda of people who

Very cool speak easy style with vintage American music and fantastic cocktail selection and bar staff. If you're looking for something off the beaten path this is a must stop in Sydney
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

A favourite watering hole, especially when introducing to friends. The atmosphere is wonderful. The first time you first step through the entrance doorway, you think you've taken a wrong turn, but keep going and all will be revealed. More

Amazing speakeasy bar with extensive selection of whiskies. Not a whisky drinker but still found it to be a great experience - very different ambience and atmosphere to most bars and similar to its sister venue Shady Pines Saloon.

Favourite bar in sydney. Visit every time. Probably the biggest and most impressive whiskey collection in the country. Old school country US playing from the speakers with free unlimited pretzels. Western saloon style. Very cool.

Whiskey themed bar with great vibes and music. Particularly loved the underground, dingy vibes. Place gets crowded so expect to wait awhile for your drinks!
Price per person
$20–40
Food: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Hidden, old-fashioned bar. Amazing ambiance! Bartenders were friendly, funny, and extremely knowledgeable of their craft. We'll be back the next time we are in Sydney!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Fun underground bar. Very nice atmosphere and the free pretzels are a welcome touch. It can get very busy, so get in early. Knowledgeable bar staff that know liqueurs well. The cocktails were delicious and unique.

If you love good quality whisky, this is the place to go! Huge selection of different whisky around the globe With the vibe like Texas in US, the ambiance will make you have a good fun with your mates! …

Nice atmosphere Finlay is best bartender, really great bants and takes care of the customer. He sends it; properly good bevies surprise
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Epic selection of whiskys and highly knowledgeable staff.. amazing experience! Was able to try Springbank and Arran whiskys which I have not seen elsewhere in Aus.. highly recommend a visit here!

Loved this experience! Great place for whiskey lovers, but even if you aren't, come anyway! You go through a back alley and down some dodgy feeling stairs, only to be brought back in time.

What a vibe! Your way to Baxter Inn is already a treasure hunt, as there are no signs to the hidden whisky bar. It was a unique experience highly recommended. Smokey Joe’s was beautiful

Quite possibly the coolest whiskey bar in the southern hemisphere.
Price per person
$60–80
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Local Whiskey

I have been to this bar a couple of times. If you want a good whiskey based cocktail, come here. Great vibe, great atmosphere. It's busy and crowded but well worth the visit.

This cocktail bar is amazing, it’s a whisky bar that was in the top 10 or top 5 around the world. It’s very dark underground cool bar
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Best Bar in Sydney. Looks like being in the movie.
Price per person
$40–60
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Pretzels

Really enjoyed this place! Cute atmosphere, huge selection of whisky and very knowledgeable staff that are happy to chat about the whiskies. Highly recommend! More

I must say, it's a whisky lover's paradise. This unique bar boasts an impressive selection of whiskies from around the world, making it a haven for enthusiasts.

Hidden Gem in Sydney, absolutely worth the sketchy stair case. A massive variety of whisky for those who enjoy it, and the bartenders are absolutely amazing.

Amazing hidden gem. Seems spooky upon entry but inside is cozy with a wonderful atmosphere. Great drinks and service, however very busy. Hard to grab a seat.

Never had food but free pretzels are pretty good! Always a good time here. Always great cocktails and a very extensive choice of whisky available More

Loved this place! It really looks like a prohibition style of bar. Large variety of drinks but I am not sure if they serve any food. More

Great atmosphere and tremendous selection of whiskey. Highly recommend all visitors or residents of Sydney to come visit.

Wow. Amazing place to explore the world of Scotch whisky.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5

Glen from Cork was the best bartender!! Made the most amazing cocktails and such a cool atmosphere.

Super fun spirited place with extensive whiskey menu and lively old school music.