Jimmy John's

167 reviews

5550 W 86th St #101, Indianapolis, IN 46268

locations.jimmyjohns.com

+13173379183

About

Jimmy John's is a Sandwich shop located at 5550 W 86th St #101, Indianapolis, IN 46268. It has received 167 reviews with an average rating of 3.7 stars.

Photos

Hours

Monday10:30AM-9PM
Tuesday10:30AM-9PM
Wednesday10:30AM-9PM
Thursday10:30AM-9PM
Friday10:30AM-9PM
Saturday10:30AM-9PM
Sunday10:30AM-9PM

F.A.Q

Frequently Asked Questions

  • The address of Jimmy John's: 5550 W 86th St #101, Indianapolis, IN 46268

  • Jimmy John's has 3.7 stars from 167 reviews

  • Sandwich shop

  • "I tried the #12 in an "unwich" style no bread"

    "I love Jimmy John's, but this one is terrible waited for :35 minutes (because I really like JJ's and am patient) before calling"

    "Horrible"

    "I decided hey instead of going to the one in traders point give this one a try since it's closer "

    "You guys are kind of the worst"

Reviews

  • Joe bickers

I tried the #12 in an "unwich" style no bread. Cause I'm watching my calories and carb intake to drop a few pounds. It's funny cause the unwich is the same price as the #12 with bread. About $10 after tax it's just lettuce and it looks like 1/2 of what would go on a regular #12 sandwich. However I liked it and will buy it again.

  • Casey Donnell

I love Jimmy John's, but this one is terrible waited for :35 minutes (because I really like JJ's and am patient) before calling. I was then informed that my sandwich hadn't even left the store! No apology only excuses and I had to request for my money back- very poor management.

  • Austin J

Horrible. Said 5-10 minutes delivery time, showed up in 35 minutes. $12.87 sandwhich with 3 slices of ham on it. Called and checked to see if that's normal, talked with manager who said that is the "standard minimum". Will not be spending that much again for a bunch of bread.

  • Twilight02

I decided hey instead of going to the one in traders point give this one a try since it's closer .. Big huge mistake ... Bread hard... Chips taste past the prime and the cookie so freaking hard . I will travel the extra miles to definitely avoid this place .. Gross

  • Melanie Nickless

You guys are kind of the worst. We ordered a tuna club sandwich that had specified onions, and pickle be added along with avocado spread for an extra charge. Got the food and the requested items were missing from the tuna club. Called it in

  • Lee Mauer

Went in at 7 this evening. The employee saw me coming to the door and cursed under his breath and thres his gloves inside out on the bread he was putting on trays to bake. As i walked in he frowned and muttered some more as if i was holding

  • Tammy Barillas

Attaching The sandwiches I received this evening. Called and spoke with a very defensive manager. I just didn't want to pay for this, was willing to return sandwiches. He argued that he made the sandwiches himself and before sending photos

  • Rob Pinder

Jimmy John’s (or Jimmy’s John’s as pronounced by their Tony Bolognavich ad character) is becoming my go to sandwich shop. Food is always great, staff is always friendly. I’m generally greeted when I enter the store and bid a good day when

  • Yadira H

Usually go to the Jimmy Johns on Township Line and have always had great experiences there but decided to stop in to this location as it was closer at that time. Went in and 3 employees were sitting at the booths and didn’t seem to notice

  • Lori K

Ugh Freaky SLOW!! Pulled up to drive through, placed order no problem. One car in front of me waiting. Took them forever to get their sandwiches. So when I pull up the cashier (Jessica) just stares at me. I said "how much" and she says "I

  • Tyson Patterson

This location is trash. I ordered a sandwich at 2.05 pm, so after the lunch rush on a day where Subway has all foot longs for $6, so an abnormally slow day for JJ's. It is now 3:05 and my lunch is still not here. I don' t know if they

  • Judy Buchanan

I visited this store and ordered a Regular Club LuLu which has lettuce, tomato & mayo traditionally. I ask to also have mustard. Drive thru time was fine however, when I got back to my office STARVING & SOOOO Ready to eat my LuLu....I

  • Mark Bailey

Despite a mediocre review history, we had a great experience at this Jimmy John's on Sunday, August 21, 2016 at about 4pm. I ordered the Gargantuan and Tracy really took the time to make sure it was made properly. It was awesome, and

  • Phillip Ross

Subs so fast youll freak is a terrible way to describe this particular location. Im a truck driver and Im at a shop not even 5 mins from this store. I ordered online and an hour later Im still waiting for it to be delivered. Ive had

  • G W

No customers in the store. Went through the drive up -- waited 5 minutes-- no aknowledgement that i was even there. I drove up to the window and 2 employees were standing behind counter talking. I drove off and went to Steak N Shake

  • D B

Sub was really good! Number 9 , the Delivery Person was Very prompt and very Professional as I was in a difficult area to Deliver to as Semi backing into the dock. Thank you Jimmy John's and Delivery Driver! Have a Happy New Year!

  • J

Good food. I wouldn't say it was freaky fast because it wasn't...more like typical slow. The people are nice and they do try to get your order correct. I will say the staff here are a lot nicer than the other Jimmy John's nearby.

  • Dee Chat

All I gotta say is BEN was awesome!! As I am a OTR TRUCK DRIVER this man went above and beyond for me. Might not mean much.. but BEN THANK YOU BROTHER FOR making a bomb sandwich and telling me about the rewards program. More

  • Maria Sitzmann

2 and a half hours after cancelling my order, a confused driver showed up.... they never cancelled my order OR gave me my food. Get DoorDash and go somewhere with better food, decent service, and competent management.

  • John Wan

Solid food place. Delivery made it expensive as it cost an additional $4 fee on top of tips. Hunter's club sandwich itself was great. I like that it was highly customizable and could add a lot of extras for free. More

  • John Barney

The food was good as with everyone of these chains I have been too. Was at this one yesterday and staff was great, today they were all mean, rude and not helpful. I don't think I'll be coming back to this one.

  • Kimberley Hokanson

Jimmy's has always treated us well. My husband got the wrong chips but I'm sure that was because we were having problems hearing them with the masks. Great food. Great service. As always. Well done Jimmy's!

  • Kristen Wells

I’ve literally never had this slow of service. There are (no joke) 12 people crammed behind the counter (supposedly working), yet it took 15 minutes to get 2 sandwiches. Ole Jimmy would be rolling heads.

  • Aquaponicliquid garden

Place is always trash.. they dont care about you here. They didnt return my credit card and i had to wait 5 days + the drive to get it and they didnt offer to help me out at all.

  • Matt Harris

Ridiculously slow service, even if it weren't a jimmy johns. Employees seem to stoned to understand simple orders and move slower than turtles stampeding through peanut butter.

  • Brent Faulk

I understand being short-staffed but the app or someone in store needs to warn you or update you if it’s going to be longer than normal. Twice now it’s been over an hour. More

  • Jim Brown

Had I not been gridlocked in the drivethru line I would have given up and gone somewhere else for lunch. Nobody moved for over 10 mins. At lunchtime. Not going back.

  • Sarah Hallenbeck

Waited for 10 minutes in drive thru for our subs while presumably the manager was chitchating to the 4 visible employees. We were the only sandwiches in queue.

  • Michael Haase

Great place to get a great sandwich. Even when they are custom orders. People there were very nice and made my order correctly. Will definitely be back. More

  • dwight turner

Not a good working environment within the company but good sandwhichs they need to work more on who they hire yet only managers within

  • BLACK HAY_ZUES

Its Jimmy Johns nothing special. I really do like their food however this location had a young man with long dirty nails....GROSS

  • Kathryn Siegel

I've had multiple issues with this Jimmy John's. They have gone to the wrong building and not contacted us, leaving us to call

  • Michael M

Good food. Would've gave five star but I think the food chain charges little much for cold cut sandwich with chips and drink.

  • Chris Conway

Why do I get sick every time I eat here? The taste isn’t bad, and is not a bad sub overall. I use to think JJ was top 5

  • John Swafford

Sorry, but there was nothing freaky fast about how they made my small sandwich. Bread may have been a little stale too.

  • Caitlin Montague

Delivery times are ridiculous. 2 hours for one sandwich, no status update and then rude when I called for status. More

  • Mande Watkins

Changed my drink at the window, and the server was super kind about it even though I had anxiety about asking lol More

  • Imari Powell

Everyone in here is always so nice and entertaining lol lots of personality at this location
Service…
More

  • Bob E

Love me some Jimmy John's! Great sandwich especially when you substitute the Wheat bread for the sub bread.

  • Irvin Nunez

It's been an hour since I ordered from this location for delivery and I have yet to receive my sandwich...

  • Brandon L

This location is always extremely fast... Freaky fast! They get busy, but the service is usually great!

  • Alexander J. Harb

For some odd reason this Jimmy John's did not come up on Google maps but I am glad I stumbled upon it.

  • Robert Lappin

Staff here are awesome! I like not having to make a bunch of decisions :-) …
Food: 5…
More

  • Michael Heyob

Very Quick & excellent sandwich. Stayed at Sybaris took maybe 10 minutes & they were at my door.

  • Brandon Dobbs

Amazing! Jimmy john's is so amazing. Cheap and fast delivery. Just excellent service.

  • Brian Liggons

Add bacon to that sandwich always delicious nice and friendly..
Food: 5…
More

  • Rachele Poynter

Love these guys! They are always the best delivery guys! So friendly and fast!

  • Joshua Pickard

Wish they had more vegetarian options super quick you can't really complain

  • Derick Eberbach

Girl working the counter working her tail off ... Food was good and quick.

  • Michael Thibideau

This. Is. My. Jam. They are dependable, consistent, and efficient.

Similar places

Penn Station East Coast Subs

780 reviews

4820 W 57th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254

Jersey Mike's Subs

714 reviews

6815 S Emerson Ave Suite F, Indianapolis, IN 46237

Penn Station East Coast Subs

661 reviews

835 Beachway Dr #7789, Indianapolis, IN 46224

Penn Station East Coast Subs

656 reviews

7910 US-31, Indianapolis, IN 46227

Penn Station East Coast Subs

634 reviews

3429 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46227

Penn Station East Coast Subs

631 reviews

6810 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46237

Subway

572 reviews

4887 Kentucky Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46221

Penn Station East Coast Subs

489 reviews

10065 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46229

Subway

418 reviews

936 E Hanna Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

414 reviews

5320 E 82nd St Suite 105, Indianapolis, IN 46250