Vanilla Bean Bakery

102 reviews

West, 2324 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260

www.vanillabean-bakery.com

+13173379470

About

Vanilla Bean Bakery is a Bakery located at West, 2324 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260. It has received 102 reviews with an average rating of 4.5 stars.

Photos

Hours

Monday11AM-4PM
Tuesday11AM-4PM
Wednesday10AM-2PM
ThursdayClosed
Friday11AM-4PM
Saturday11AM-4PM
Sunday11AM-4PM

F.A.Q

Frequently Asked Questions

  • The address of Vanilla Bean Bakery: West, 2324 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260

  • Vanilla Bean Bakery has 4.5 stars from 102 reviews

  • Bakery

  • "I have tried to truffles, cookies and cake pops, they have always been super good"

    "Vanilla Bean Bakery makes some of the most beautifully decorated cakes for a reasonable price"

    "Amazing cupcakes!! I emailed and asked for a dozen assorted cupcakes for my wife's birthday"

    "While the customer service was great the cupcakes and truffles were nothing but disappointing, they lack flavor"

    "Always love going here and seeing what is available behind the counter"

Reviews

  • Phillip Levi

I have tried to truffles, cookies and cake pops, they have always been super good. I got brownies the other day and I don’t know what to say other than wow! They were both Cakey and Fudgy. To me they were the perfect brownie. The only regret is that I don’t live closer, so that I could have these every day, Yum Yum!

  • Sarah Boyd

Vanilla Bean Bakery makes some of the most beautifully decorated cakes for a reasonable price. All of their cakes and cupcakes taste divine! Staff are friendly and very helpful about custom orders. Visit their Instagram account to see lots of great examples of decorating - then get to the store and have a cupcake!

  • Brian Lohroff

Amazing cupcakes!! I emailed and asked for a dozen assorted cupcakes for my wife's birthday. We were not disappointed not only did we love the way they looked but we loved every bite. If you are looking for cupcakes or delicious sweet treats I would highly recommend Vanilla Bean Bakery even in these trying times.

  • Daria Greer

While the customer service was great the cupcakes and truffles were nothing but disappointing, they lack flavor. I ordered lemon, vanilla and oreo and they all pretty much taste the same nasty and lacking sugar and moisture. The one day I decided to have a cheat day and I’m the one who got cheated

  • Gloria Heidelberger

Always love going here and seeing what is available behind the counter. Staff is always so nice and helpful. We order a somewhat large order a couple times a year for work events and Vanilla Bean has NEVER failed us!! Hard working and caring staff. The cupcakes are always beautiful and delicious.

  • Carol Wakefield

We ordered 250 picture cookies for our event and they were beautiful and delicious! Kristy and Jim were great to work with from start to finish. I would highly recommend this darling small business. ( Stop in and treat yourself to some of their beautiful cupcakes. You’ll be glad you did) …

  • Jessica Foster

Great customer service! Ordered a cake for my mom's 60th bday. I was stuck in traffic on my way to get the cake and was extremely late in picking it up (way after hours). They were so kind and waited for me to get there. The cake was delicious and we'll be going back again soon!

  • Josetta Caudill

Not only are these cupcakes delicious (I took some to a graduation party last month), they can get ready a dozen cupcakes in about 10 minutes, 20 minutes before closing, when you have a "cupcake emergency". Thank you so much for helping me out. The cupcakes are beautiful!

  • Kathleen Church

Vanilla bean bakery pulled through for us and delivered 5 adorable cookie decorating boxes to our door! The cookies were delicious and had everything we could need for decorating. We will definitely be using this bakery in the future! Thanks again!

  • Jillian Kinzie

Was hopeful but ended up disappointed. Cupcake frosting tasted like it came from a tub, and cake had little flavor or stale, oily taste. Vanilla and Boston cream bad, red velvet flavorless. Better cakes from Gigis, and Simply cupcakes. Darn.

  • Maha Kamal

I sent my best friend surprise birthday cupcakes (under quarantine)! Little did I know she ordered herself some cupcakes from Vanilla Bean too. They were happy to refund her after MY cupcakes were delivered earlier than scheduled. Thanks VB

  • Heidi Mayo

The lady working was clearly training the other on the register. No problems with customer service. No problems placing an order. The Boston Creme Cupcake is a fantastic idea. But I purchased 6 cupcakes with 5 varieties and had no interest

  • Kimberly DeGuglielmo

I had a wonderful experience using the Vanilla Bean Bakery. I needed to get a dozen cupcakes for my boss's birthday. I called several places and none of them were open. I called the Vanilla Bean Bakery and they were open and could provide

  • Jay B

I don’t like leaving negative reviews but these cupcakes were bland. I ordered four different flavors and they all tasted like flour.I’m a chocolate lover and I was severely disappointed to find that this was not a true chocolate cupcake.

  • Pam Walker

This bakery is phenomenal! I’ve used them now on a few occasions and every single time they get my vision perfectly. The flavors are all so good (cinnamon, strawberry, lemon, pink champagne, etc) and their designs are adorable. Kristy has

  • R M

The cake itself was amazing and super moist. I ordered a complex Grateful Dead themed birthday cake topped with a Jerry Garcia, Bertha skeleton, dancing bears, roses, and tie dye on inside and out. Kristy did an amazing job! The amount of

  • songan hua

The customer service was wonderful. The design of the cake was good. However, the taste was truly disappointing. When I placed the order, I clearly stated that I want a flavor that would be different that what I can get from Walmart or

  • Rebecca Blalock

Just grabbed 8 cupcakes on our way home today. They look great, appealing to the eye. When we got home and sampled them, we were so disappointed. The icing is not buttercream. It is more of a whipped, but it leaves a strange film/after

  • Julie H

What a pleasant find off the internet!! EXCELLENT customer service and the product is delicious! I had a tough time coming with an idea for my company's 15th anniversary. We have a plain logo and focus on cybersecurity, but the cake

  • Amber Toomer

Great customer service; patient and informative while I made my selection. Placing an order was easy and pickup was seamless. Our guests thoroughly enjoyed the gourmet cupcakes. We will certainly keep them in mind for future events.

  • Bailey Braun

We are so happy we chose to work with Kristy and the entire Vanilla Bean team for our wedding cake and cupcakes. We were blown away with how genuine and kind Kristy and the entire staff were throughout the entire process. Kristy was

  • Courtney Robbins

I have been meaning to write this review, but I have let time get away. I ordered several dozen individually wrapped cookies for an outdoor graduation in summer 2020. While they looked fine, they tasted horrible. Honestly Kroger or

  • Zunaira Chaudhry

These cupcakes are so good! the owner was nice to us. And customer service was great!The cupcake my daughter once got was cookies and cream and she said it was delicious. So I got one for myself. I definitely recommend this place.

  • Linda Roessler

Katie was excellent! I appreciate the time she took to help me design my husband's surprise birthday cake. It was beautiful and delicious! A complete hit! I highly recommend and will definitely be a repeat customer!

  • Maritha Spates

I love ordering my cakes from vanilla bean bakery. The service is always top notch. Kristy is AMAZING and has never failed my expectations. Thank you for all you do.. I have been a loyal customer since 2015. …

  • Kayla Roseberry

This place is amazing! People were raving over their cupcakes at my wedding! Perfect icing to cake ratio! And the detail on the Harry Potter grooms cake was wayyyy impressive! Thank you Vanilla Bean Bakery!!

  • Amanda D'Agostino Budyach

We used the Vanilla Bean Bakery for decorated sugar cookies as part of our favors for a baby shower. They were beautiful, and tasted delicious. We got so many compliments on them. Highly recommend!

  • Jennifer Schumaker

I had a cake emergency, and this place saved me!!! I called and was able to get six delicious mixed cupcakes and a batch of cake pops same day!! They were so nice, and it was all delicious!

  • Angela Serino

My husband and I visited here for the first time today. We were in the area shopping and going out for lunch. We bought 2 cupcakes - one chocolate with chocolate icing, and one chocolate

  • Laura Schroeder

Delicious, beautiful products made by super-creative, very helpful staff. They worked with us on our custom order to produce a unique collection of desserts for our event. Recommend!

  • Sharon Crooke

The owners were very helpful. I can preorder my choices and pick them up or do the delivery service. My choices were delicious. Look online for the party choices that you can order

  • Mase B

My friends got some cupcakes here and, while they may seem pricey, the cupcakes are made and iced on site. A lot of the stuff is made on site. It's worth the price I promise

  • Mindy Rainwater

The truffles are to die for!! Absolutely amazing taste and texture. The brownies were also very tasty. I live over 30 minutes away and make the drive just to get truffles!

  • AnnMarie Lucas

I love the truffles! But they need some sort of deal on the more you buy the better the price...example- buy 12 get 1 free....or a frequent flyer card....I go alot....lol

  • Stephen Johnson

Placed a gift delivery order from Houston for a friend in Indy . The staff was very helpful and friendly. The cupcakes and other goodies were wonderful! Thanks!

  • Nancy Smith

Deserts made with care by dedicated bakers. We ordered cupcakes for the entire office and were pleased with both the treats as well as the price for the order.

  • Megan

I had a 80/90s themed girls night party and ordered a dozen cupcakes. We absolutely LOVED them and they tasted great. Kristy was so sweet. Thank you so much!

  • Matt

The best of the best. I was introduced to the Vanilla Bean Bakery by our receptionist while I was

  • Judy Egbert

Always great. Always fresh. Fresh icing is put on cupcakes when you order.

  • Ed Rivera

If you call ahead, they can do sugar free cupcakes!! Best bakery ever!

Similar places

Long's Bakery

6834 reviews

1453 N Tremont St, Indianapolis, IN 46222

Long's Bakery

3162 reviews

2301 E Southport Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46227

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Castleton

1354 reviews

5520 Castleton Corner Ln, Indianapolis, IN 46250

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Township Line

1207 reviews

2370 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260

MCL Restaurant & Bakery Southside

1184 reviews

3630 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46227

The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers

950 reviews

6515 Carrollton Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Gallery Pastry Shop

932 reviews

4573 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205

Taylor's Bakery

798 reviews

6216 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Boyden's Southside Bakery

728 reviews

3953 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46217

Mama Ines Mexican Bakery

584 reviews

2001 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46222